The Curse of Jerry Hairston, Jr./Eric Hinske:
 

Monday, February 25, 2008

Looking Ahead to 2008 - Alex Rodriguez

Alex Rodriguez opted out of his contract with the Yankees during the World Series. For a few weeks it looked like his time with the Yankees was over and the team would have a huge hole to fill at third base.

What happened after that is open to several interpretations. The market seemingly did not bear what Rodriguez's agent Scott Boras had promised him, so he initiated contact with the Yankees who had made bold proclamations that if Rodriguez had opted out, they would not re-sign him. From there the Yankees and Rodriguez negotiated, allegedly without Boras and Rodriguez was brought back on a ten year contract.

It is my opinion that Rodriguez put the blame on Boras to help him get some of the egg off his face after what was a PR disaster. Boras works for Rodriguez, it's not the other way around.

Frankly, none of that really matters in the big picture. Business is business, and I have no problems with Rodriguez using the opt-out clause that was negotiated into his contract, although I will admit I was pretty pissed when he first opted out.

The Yankees are a much better team with Rodriguez than without him. If Rodriguez performs well, all this contract stuff should end up being a non-issue although it's doubtful the media will let it go away if at all possible. We've reset the A-Rod cover counter for 2008, but for 2007 Rodriguez made the front or back page of the NY Post and NY Daily News 137 separate times. Let's see if he can top that in 2008.

2007
By just about any objective measure, Rodriguez was the best player in baseball last season. How good was Rodriguez? His lowest OPS at any point in the season was .976, which was his OPS after three games. That was the only day that his OPS was under 1, and the last day of the season that his OPS was under 1.022.

Here's how Rodriguez performed compared to his projections going into 2007.

2007 PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO HBP AVG OBP SLG BR/650
Avg Projection 650 557 107 162 26 1 34 110 15 4 81 127 10 .292 .390 .529 108
Actual 708 583 143 183 31 0 54 156 24 4 95 120 21 .314 .422 .645 136
% Diff 9% 5% 22% 3% 8% -100% 45% 31% 46% -3% 7% -14% 102% 8% 8% 22% 26%


The percentage differences for everything except PA and AB are on a rate basis. Rodriguez was disgraceful, hitting no triples despite being projected to hit one in what was clearly a disappointing season.

I kid of course. Rodriguez blew away his projections. He hit 22 pts higher than projected on batting average, hit 45% more HRs on a rate basis, walked 7% more frequently and struck out 14% less frequently (this was key IMO). He stole more bases than expected, and he provided 26% more offense according to linear weights on a rate basis. Rodriguez illustrates one of the major limitations with projection systems, they just aren't designed to handle the outliers.

Rodriguez was also able to get the "unclutch" monkey off his back, by hitting several key game-winning HRs in the ninth inning.
April 7 vs. Chris Ray
April 19 vs. Joe Borowski
June 3 vs. Jon Papelbon

Rodriguez hit .318/.448/.776 with runners in scoring position and two outs. He hit .357/.439/.686 in Late & Close situations (PA in the 7th or later with the batting team tied, ahead by one, or the tying run at least on deck.). His worst split? When the margin of the game was greater than four runs (.218/.375/.540).

Unfortunately, Rodriguez had another disappointing post-season as the Yankees were eliminated in four games by Cleveland in the ALDS. He didn't hit particularly poorly overall thanks to a two hit game in Game 4 including a HR, but he got some grief regardless. Anyone that says that losing the ALDS was Rodriguez's fault is being foolish, but he didn't help as much as he could have.

Offense
2007 is over and done, so what can we look for in 2008? Thanks to last season, all the projection systems expect better from Rodriguez at age 32 than they did in heading into his age 31 season.

Projection PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO HBP AVG OBP SLG BRAA BRAR
chone 653 551 124 167 25 1 47 123 16 4 88 122 14 .303 .412 .608 51 67
marcel 621 525 108 157 26 1 36 116 17 4 79 118 12 .299 .399 .558 39 54
pecota 684 572 120 169 34 2 36 116 23 4 94 130 11 .294 .401 .550 43 59
zips 698 590 127 180 30 1 44 151 16 3 93 132 15 .305 .413 .583 51 68
cairo 689 581 123 174 27 1 43 129 19 4 90 128 14 .299 .403 .570 46 63
average 669 564 121 169 28 1 41 127 18 4 89 126 13 .300 .406 .574 46 62


For more information on the projections being used here, you can look at the first entry in this series.

Rodriguez projects to be somewhere between 5 to 7 wins better than a replacement level 3B in 2008, on average around 6 wins better. CAIRO lines up fairly well with the other projections, sort of in the middle. Here's how CAIRO sees Rodriguez's range of projections.

CAIRO % PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO HBP AVG OBP SLG BRAA BRAR
80% 689 581 135 187 33 2 49 140 24 2 99 117 18 .322 .442 .639 68 85
65% 689 581 129 181 30 1 46 134 21 3 95 122 16 .311 .422 .604 57 74
Baseline 689 581 123 174 27 1 43 129 19 4 90 128 14 .299 .403 .570 46 63
35% 689 581 118 167 25 0 39 123 17 5 85 134 12 .288 .384 .536 35 51
20% 689 581 112 161 22 0 36 117 15 6 80 139 10 .277 .365 .501 24 40


Rodriguez is so good that even the 80% projection doesn't seem that unrealistic. His 20% projection would be considered disappointing but it would STILL be 4 wins better than a replacement level 3B. This is a great player, and he's going to be a Yankee for the next ten years, so for the vocal minority that still dislikes him, WTF is wrong with you? To quote the great Ric Flair:
Whether you like it, or you don't like it, learn to love it, because it's the best thing going today.


The sooner the Yankee fans who dislike Rodriguez embrace him, the sooner they'll get to enjoy the play of the best player on the team.

Defense
Lost in the monstrous season by Rodriguez offensively was the fact that he played much better defense as well. He ended the season a smidgen above average by zone rating, but he was actually pretty solidly above average most of the season. On July 23 Rodriguez's zone rating was .821 compared to the AL average of .765 and he had made around 14 plays more than an average AL 3B, which was roughly equivalent to saving 11 runs above average to that point and 19 runs over 162 games. Over the remaining 57 games Rodriguez's zone rating was only .669 and he made somewhere around 11 plays fewer than average. To my eyes he didn't seem to play any worse in the second half although he made 7 errors over 130 chances as opposed to 6 errors over his first 240 chances, so he may have just faced harder opportunities. Still, overall it was a nice rebound after a couple of pretty bad defensive seasons.

Year Pos GP Innings PO A E DP PM CH ZR PMAA RSAA RSAA/162
2004 3B 155 1364 100 262 13 25 286 364 .786 14 11 12
2005 3B 161 1385 115 288 12 26 321 436 .736 -15 -12 -13
2006 3B 151 1288 96 262 24 24 289 390 .741 -10 -8 -9
2007 3B 154 1330 106 251 13 30 283 370 .765 2 1 1
Projection 155 1334 104 262 16 27 292 387 .755 -4 -3 -4


Between his below average play in 2005 and 2006 and the fact that he's going to be another year older, I project Rodriguez to be about 3-4 runs below average in 2008. I think his bat can carry that though...

Baserunning
Not only can Rodriguez hit well and field passably, he's an outstanding baserunner too. By Lee Panas's bases gained above average, Rodriguez gained 11.8 bases above average on hits, 2.7 on grounders, 2.5 on fly outs, and another 11.1 on other situations. Good for 28.1 total BGAA, which ranked sixth in the AL. I'd regress that some for 2008 and say a conservative projection would be something like +15.

Value
Well, Rodriguez has the biggest contract in baseball history. Is he worth it?

Value Runs Wins
Offense 62 6.2
Defense -3 -0.3
Baserunning 4 0.4
Overall Value 63 6.3
2008 Value (in millions) 27.2
2008 Salary (in millions) 27.0
Difference 0.2


At least for 2008, Rodriguez's compensation is in line with his projection of being 6.3 wins above replacement level overall. His contract is going to start looking worse as he gets older and further away from his peak, although inflation will help to mitigate that at least partially. I also tend to think that a linear look at value penalizes a star player like Rodriguez. What I mean by that is in theory a pair of three win players are as valuable as one six win player on paper, but the fact that Rodriguez only takes up one roster spot to get you those six wins has some inherent value as well, especially for a large revenue team.

Conclusion
As a fan, I really looked forward to Rodriguez's at-bats last season. It's hard to put it in words, but there was something cool about the anticipation watching the people in front of Rodriguez doing whatever they could to get on base to set up the big guy in the cleanup spot to do his magic, and he did it all year. This is a Hall of Famer who may have just had the best season of his career at age 31 and he should continue to be the best player on the team for the next few years. More than any player on the team, Rodriguez will be the difference between the Yankees making or missing the playoffs. Let's hope he can stay healthy, and let's hope the rest of the team can contribute to get them to the playoffs. From there, maybe Rodriguez will have the postseason that he probably needs to have to FINALLY get accepted as a Yankee.

Plug Time
Francis Gasparini, bka fgasparini in the comments section here pointed me to his podcast called Widely Ranging Interests, which can be accessed at widelyranginginterests.com. It's not about baseball, but there is more to life than baseball, isn't there?
--Posted at 8:46 am by SG / 33 Comments | - (1110)

Comments

Page 1 of 1 pages:

“His contract is going to start looking worse as he gets older and further away from his peak, although inflation will help to mitigate that at least partially. “

That’s all true but also I forget what the exact numbers are, and I’m too lazy to check Cot’s, but A-Rod’s contract is front loaded so he’s making the most money in the first few years of the deal then makes less toward the end.

When your baseline projected OPS is .973, you’re probably doing something right.  As far as players being fun to watch, last year was a toss-up between A-Rod and Joba.

Though SG went into the general “clutchness” of A-Rod, I think it’s further worth noting that he absolutely carried the team during its horrific start - he seemingly single-handedly won a bunch of those early games, enough to keep their head just above water.  And then he kept pouring it on even as they were in a race and the other hitters started producing.  Just an awesome, awesome year.  It was fun listening to the naysayers - mouths full of crow - babble incoherently about A-Rod last year.  WTF!? indeed.

I feel better everyday about the yankees finishing in first place.

Just a quick question - why does it show the difference in hits projected/actual as only being 3%?

That’s all true but also I forget what the exact numbers are, and I’m too lazy to check Cot’s, but A-Rod’s contract is front loaded so he’s making the most money in the first few years of the deal then makes less toward the end.

True, I forgot about that, although the HR milestone bonuses could change that.  $27 million this year, $32 million in 2009 and 2010, then it starts to go down.

Just a quick question - why does it show the difference in hits projected/actual as only being 3%?

I divided everything by plate appearances except for plate appearances and at bats.  So Rodriguez was projected to have 162 hits in 650 plate appearances, .249 H/PA.  He actually had 183 hits in 708 plate appearances, .258 H/PA.  That’s where the 3% comes in.  If I did it by AB then it’d match the 8% difference shown in batting average.

I never had you pegged as a Flair fan, SG. Although I probably should’ve, given the Atlanta thing. Maybe we can get Alex to come up to the plate in some of those robes. I feel like that would help his image.

A-Rod is like good and stuff.

i also expect the media circus to begin to wane a bit as he will never have to negotiate another contract again.  he’s a yankee now. 

oh, who am i kidding?  the guy got criticized by some fans for saying Jeter would have an “MVP season”.

I never had you pegged as a Flair fan, SG. Although I probably should’ve, given the Atlanta thing.

Nah, it’s not an Atlanta thing.  I was a Flair fan before I moved down here.  It’s more the fact that we share the same limousine-riding, jet-flying lifestyle.

A-Rod is like good and stuff.

That was my first draft of this entry.

I think that June 3rd game took about 6 months off my life.  The Cano triple was awesome to tie the score off of Okijhima, but when they couldn’t bring him in with no outs, I was furious, but watching ARod homer off of Paplebon was worth it.

It’s pretty amazing that ARod is “worth” his contract this year, especially when you consider that marginal wins probably are worth more to the Yankees, and that’s not even counting the “star power” revenue he garners.  You also make a good point about concentration of talent, which is important for high-revenue teams.

Yeah, that June 3rd game was awesome, especially since it was on my birthday, of course I only barely remember it.

A-Rod’s MVP comment about Jeter either:

A) reveals A-Rod doesn’t know how to inspire teammates with grit and intangibles
B) was meant to needle Jeter about never winning the award
C) was meant to jinx Jeter because A-Rod’s so jealous of him
D) was meant to predispose writers to vote for Justin Morneau next Septemberinstead
E) all of the above

and he should continue to be the best player on the team for the next few years.

I’m going to go out on a (pretty sturdy I think) limb and say that in either 2009 or 2010, Cano is going to pass ARod as “best player on the team”.  Not really because ARod is going to slip, but because I think Cano will excel.  From a pure #‘s standpoint (e.g. OPS) I think ARod will still have a slight lead, but when adjusting for position and defense, I think Cano will come out on top.  Mind you it’s just a hunch…

A team full of hitters whose 80% projections matched Rodriguez’ 20% projection would be really freakin’ good.  Unless they were all lefthanded or something.  It would be pretty rough having an infield full of lefthanded throwers.

Digging through the mainstream media, it would appear there is a buzz of sorts surrounding LaTroy Hawkins.  The only problem, however, is that his two-seamer might not play as well now that Troy Tulowitzki won’t be manning shortstop behind him.  That being said, he signed a one year deal and allowed Cashman to cut Vizcaino loose - which nets a sandwich pick.

WOOOOO!....I like the nature boy reference. I hated on Arod for a while until last season. He really opened my eyes as to what is possible to do on a baseball field.

I was in new orleans watching the walk off against chris ray on mlb.tv with my friend who is an orioles fan. A great moment for me last season.

I enjoyed the HR off Borowski myself, as it capped a rally in which the Yankees, down by 4 runs with two outs in the 9th inning, took a game they had no business winning.  In some cosmic way, I felt that was owed to the Yanks after Mariano Rivera inexplicably had given up a two out, three run walkoff HR to Marco Scutaro of all people, in the preceding weeks.

It’s all been said already, but A-Rod took what was a HOF career and catapulted it to the forefront with his 2007 season.  Every at-bat was an experience.  I remember sitting ten rows behind home plate and the crowd just going nuts when he was about to bat.  I’ll never forget that season.  Yeah, the Yankees didn’t win the world series.  But I got to see one of the greatest hitters ever have possibly the best season of his career.  Breathtaking.

he really was awesome last year.

i think the peak of his season was when Seattle rolled into town and they weren’t going away in the WC, and Alex just put them down like a horse with a broken leg.

the Yankees had lost the first game of the series and they were tied in the los column with Seattle, then won the next 2. 

both games were close for 6-7 innings and A-Rod hit clutch HRs in both games, and the eventually broke open both games into blowouts.

the yanks never looked back.

I was listening to that Borowski game while I was working last year, I remember thinking that they should just walk ARod and risk a hit than face him… Then I was really glad that Eric Wedge didn’t take my mental advice.

Great piece, SG.

I am so happy A-Rod decided not to become a heel. That would have irritated me greatly.

Hey guys

i scoped this love-fest and just had to join in. a welcome sight after months of agitated nitpickiness!

my a-rod moment was yup’s. i was at that game where Phil was having what seemed like a rough go against the M’s the first couple innings before he sharpened up, and then Jose Molina hit a homer to keep us close. duncan threw ibanez out at second. rod hit i think 47 and 48 in the 7th. it was magically delicious. joba got his 1st career win and oh vernon wells beasted the sox that night which was the one useful thing he did all year aside from that fake catch he pulled on johnny damon.

I don’t buy A-Rod doing poorly in the 2007 “postseason.”  He had no protection behind him in the order (Torre deserves some blame for that), and they didn’t advance beyond the division series.  He had one bad game, and the rest of it wasn’t too bad.  So, the sample size is too small to put such a bad label on him,  and what we saw wasn’t as bad as the media would lead us to believe.

thurm—

Dogfish Head 90-minute IPA.

Oh yes, oh yes, oh yes it is.

Seein the light are ya lad?

TommyBorasD… Gimme an effin break. Wee alex is blowin dead geese when the leaves turn and everyone here knows it. I refuse to participate in this Nimrod pornfest.
Whats next? Pettite as a drug free righthanded agnostic?
Clemens as someone you would introduce to your sister?

Gee you’re right Thurm.  I guess A-Rod sucks after all.  Thanks for setting us straight.  I wish he’d just taken his no-postseason-talent ass outta New York. I gotta tell you it must be that postseason sample sizes aren’t the smallest things these stastic guys are sporting.

Maybe, but:

Pettite as a drug free righthanded agnostic?
Clemens as someone you would introduce to your sister?

is superb work.

Dave.. I’m not saying he sucks.
I am saying blaming Torre, Matsui and Jorge for his October malfunctions could be a bit unfair.
Alex at this point has a fairly vast postseason portfolio.
Lot of ugly games there.
I believe he has said ” I haven’t got it done”
Stastics doan lye.

In other news…found out today about Phil Hughes’s blog.  Not sure if anyone mentioned it before.  So far at least not exactly a lot of in-depth stuff, but kind of neat.

I’ve seen it… I wonder how it will go as the season progresses.

Thurm - the full body of ARod’s postseason work is still solid, IIRC.  Since game 4 of the ‘04 ALCS, however, it’s pretty bad.  There are some excellent players on the team whose stats since that time are bad too.  Just about the only one who keeps hitting in Oct seems (to me, anyway) to be Cano.

Oh, and 90-minute IPA is powerful, powerful stuff.  Not my thing, IPA, but I recall coming across a “Brown IPA” or somesuch that packed a heckuva punch and was awfully yummy to boot.

I think I saw an A-Rod cover yesterday.  When does the counting start?  Opening Day?

I think we can start it now.  I’ve got two to post.

Page 1 of 1 pages:
1 of 963 registered readers are currently logged in.
There are currently 62 visitors who are not logged in.
There was a record 241 simultaneous visitors on May 2, 2011 at 11:54:25 pm.

Logged in users: PredX


Does Robinson Cano’s Approach Change With Men on Base?
(50 Comments - 1/26/2010 10:44:25 am)

2010 CAIRO Projections v0.2
(14 Comments - 1/25/2010 10:56:33 pm)

One Of The Following Stories May or May Not Be True
(26 Comments - 1/25/2010 1:51:23 pm)

What Happened to Wang?
(13 Comments - 1/24/2010 11:53:14 pm)

NY Times - Glanville: Seeing is Disbelieving
(62 Comments - 1/24/2010 9:27:27 pm)

RealGM Baseball: Yankees Among Teams Interested In Edmonds
(3 Comments - 1/23/2010 4:52:40 pm)

Should Jesus Montero Be an Option for Left Field?
(65 Comments - 1/22/2010 10:24:20 am)

CAIRO Projected 2010 AL East Standings as of January 16
(35 Comments - 1/21/2010 2:53:01 pm)

MLB.com - Bauman: Yankees appear stronger
(18 Comments - 1/21/2010 5:21:26 am)

TSBG Versus High and Low Fastballs
(5 Comments - 1/20/2010 9:00:27 am)



*ADVERTISEMENT*
Our new URL is: http://www.rlyw.net
*ADVERTISEMENT*

*ADVERTISEMENT*

image
Way back in the 20th century, Bill James wrote the first essential book about baseball managers. Chris Jaffe has just written the second.
- Rob Neyer, ESPN.com

From now on, whenever I have a question about a manager, Jaffe's book will be the first and last one I reach for.
- Sean Forman, Baseball-Reference.com


*ADVERTISEMENT*

*ADVERTISEMENT*
John Brattain Memorial Fund

The Hardball Times has set up a memorial fund for John Brattain's family. He left behind a wife and two teenage daughters.

Four years ago, I found from personal experience how generous the online community can be to its own in their hour of need. I am now literally begging you to be even more generous than you were to me.


*ADVERTISEMENT*

*ADVERTISEMENT*

*ADVERTISEMENT*

*ADVERTISEMENT*

*ADVERTISEMENT*